When one analyzes the character relations in e Tempest based on a .. e relationship between Prospero and Ariel is not entirely unambiguous: not only . of their relationship because Prospero even takes advice from Ariel in V.i. (note. A detailed writing frame to help pupils produce an essay answering the question- describe the relationship between Ariel and Prospero-. Includes a lesson powerpoint, extract from Act 1 scene 2 and quotes about their relationship.
In other words, in that world, Ariel will not need to pass through the phases of enslaved labour in order to realize his full potential. Shakespeare Birthplace Trust I like this analysis, but then it raises questions about what happens next, If Ariel acquires a mind of his own through work, what happens when he is set free?
Is this not an ironic ending? Also I am interested in the assumption lurking under this analysis that Ariel needs Prospero to reach his full potential and that the enslavement is in some ways useful and even empowering. The idea of co-dependency is interesting in relation to The Tempest and it is often represented as such on the stage, with master needing servant as well as servant needing master. Shakespeare Birthplace Trust Insightful as ever, Christian. One of the things which I have always found interesting about the tempest is how well Caliban and Ariel know eachother.
Their relationship if such it is is a resounding blank. Your suggestion that Caliban and Ariel work together to overthrow Prospero is one oddly neglected by Shakespeare. Christian Smith I agree with Zsolt that there is more to the story than what I wrote in my comment and will take his suggestion to extend my interpretation in light of Hegel and Marx.
In paragraph of Ph. After much time of being alienated from his labour power the worker loses the possibility of this philosophically-contrived consciousness and succumbs to an emptying of his Geist. It is emptied of its knowledge about its actual situation and of its history.
Consequently it is emptied of the consciousness of its revolutionary future. Marx uses quotes from and allusions to Shylock to describe a Geist with its heart cut out — the reified consciousness.
Ariel sinks the ship and distributes the crew on the island. Ariel enchants Ferdinand and the others with his music and then saves the King from regicide.
He tricks the conspirators and then torments them with the Harpies. Ariel drives the characters all over the island and in the end, it is Ariel who attires Prospero. Lurking under the surface of this play is the possibility that at any point, Ariel could have gone on strike, or, worse, united with Caliban and defeated the humans.
Ariel seems to have become alienated from his power. When Ariel has acquired a mind of his own he tells Prospero to be empathic. To see the suffering of his usurpers-turned-captives and to forgive them.
Ariel moves Geist to the state of mutual recognition. It will, of course, take more work to rehabilitate Sebastian and Antonio. Well, Gonzalo dreamed it up for us.
Ariel (The Tempest) - Wikipedia
Nevertheless, I think that this dialectic may be developed in another direction as well. This continuation of the story has not always been recognized, although this continuation may well be applicable to The Tempest too, if one intends to stick to reading the text in the light of the Master -Slave dialectic.
Also the work power that is required from Caliban is a complicated issue, as he is not represented as someone who would act as a proper slave. In the final act, Ariel releases the prisoners of Prospero and awakens what is left of the crew of the ship from a deep slumber. Thanks to Ariel's work, Ferdinand and Miranda have fallen in love.
Prospero is so impressed by Ariel's matchmaking that he says that he would set Ariel free for that one act. Thus, having fulfilled Prospero's tasks, and Prospero himself now being free to leave the island, Ariel is set free.
Sources[ edit ] The source from which Shakespeare got the idea for Ariel is not known, though there have been many candidates proposed by scholars. Sprites or demons such as Ariel were viewed during the Renaissance from either religious or scientific points of view: Some scholars compare Ariel to demons of the air described in Renaissance demonologywhile others claim that he is an archetype of a more neutral category of sprites.Ariel and Caliban character analysis, the tempest
These spirits often disturb the air, stir up tempests and thunders. They do not retain one form, but take on various forms Jewish demonology, for example, had a figure by the name of Ariel who was described as the spirit of the waters.
Another spirit, Urielis also comparable. In Isaiah 29, an Ariel is mentioned as another name for Jerusalem.
In the Geneva Bible, which Shakespeare and others of the time would have known, the entry carries an interesting footnote describing this Ariel as the "Lyon of God. Other scholars propose that the ca. The character, named Shrimp, is also an air demon controlled by a magician.
A few scenes of the play feature this demon performing tasks nearly identical to those Shakespeare's Ariel performed. Since it is very likely Shakespeare was familiar with the play, it is possible that Ariel is based on Shrimp, but evidence remains inconclusive.
Shakespeare, however, refuses to make Ariel a will-less character, infusing him with desires and near-human feelings uncharacteristic of most sprites of this type.
Scholars have tried to discover just what sort of "quainte device" would have been used by the King's Men in portraying this scene. Ariel's actor would have been unable to hide the food himself, having harpy wings over his arms which cumbered movement. The actor would not even have been able to sweep the food into a receptacle behind the table, since the theatre had seating on three sides. What was needed was some sort of device to act on the signal of Ariel slapping his wings on the table.
The Tempest – Ariel, Prospero and Caliban – a very wonky triangle - Blogging Shakespeare
This device was probably a false table top which could be tripped by a boy underneath while the harpy's wings covered the food. When the wings lifted, the food would be gone, apparently by magic. Later in act three, when Ariel appears and disappears with thunder, another trick was probably used, involving some sort of basket on wires, covered in cloud designs, which the Globe theatre then had.
Ariel may have descended from the air in this device as a harpy, spoken his lines, and ascended in the same device. Ariel may have descended on the back of an eagle, rather than clouds, or with no device at all—wires being attached to his harpy wings.
Scholars have wondered whether Shakespeare originally intended the actor for Ariel to cover Ceres' role, and give it away in this line.
The need for a dual role may have been caused by a shortage of boys capable of playing female parts boys usually played all female roles in Shakespeare's day as there are many female roles in The Tempest. This changing of parts requires a change in costume, which explains a lot of Ariel's delay in scene four in carrying out Prospero's orders.
Time is allowed for the character to change from Ariel to Ceres and back. On the other side, Ceres may have been associated, by Shakespeare, to the Kairos figure, related to rhetorics, personating the opportune moment to present the convincing argument in a speech.
More recent studies, however, have revealed that, given the small number of boys travelling with the King's Men and the large number of parts for them to fill, there would have been little choice in the matter.
The entire scene comes together in a way that leads scholars to believe that the Masque scene with the three goddesses was added as an afterthought to work around costuming and role-playing issues. One example is in the stage directions at III. Enter ARIEL, like a harpy; claps his wings upon the table; and, with a quaint device, the banquet vanishes. All hail, great master! I come To answer thy best pleasure; be't to fly, To swim, to dive into the fire, to ride On the curl'd clouds; to thy strong bidding task Ariel and all his quality.